Eloquence, however, is not as important as kindness, concern, and a straightforward declaration of belief. Will Campbell has been a Baptist preacher, civil rights activist, farmer, writer, and volunteer cook for his friend Waylon Jennings. Years ago, he was invited to participate in a student conference on capital punishment at Florida State University. At the last minute he discovered that he was supposed to formally debate an erudite scholar, who delivered a long philosophical argument in favor of the death penalty as a means of buttressing the legitimacy of the state. When Campbell got up to present the opposing view, nothing equally weighty came to mind. So he said, slowly and deliberately, "I just think it's tacky," and sat down.
The audience laughed.
"Tacky?" the moderator asked.
"Yessir," Campbell repeated. "I just think it's tacky."
"Now, come on," the moderator said, "tacky is an old Southern word, and it means uncouth, ugly, lack of class."
"Yessir. I know what it means," said Campbell. "And if a thing is ugly, well, ugly means there's no beauty there. And if there is no beauty in it, there is no truth in it. And if there is no truth in it, there is no good in it. Not for the victim of the crime. Certainly not for the one being executed. Not for the executioner, the jury, the judge, the state. For no one. And we were enjoined by a well-known Jewish prophet to love them all."
I'm not lobbying for disdaining reasoned arguments. But modern society, by virtue of its complexity and sophistication, makes moral engagement difficult; we don't need to compound the problem by demanding perfection. Simple can still be forceful and eloquent.
Friday, July 01, 2005
From article by Paul Loeb...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Questions for change
Progress Engage in Solidarity What in individual life can be better? How do we make the world better? Find thing to WIN. Heal ourselves Trus...
-
Probably as important as dandruff.. Today I commend our Senator Boxer on her amendment to stop the Gag Order. Senate Passes Boxer-Snowe Prov...
-
By Matt Taibbi May 11, 2011 9:30 AM ET They weren't murderers or anything; they had merely stolen more money than most people can ...
-
Another reason why this "reign" is BAD for America.... Bush Grabs New Power for FBI By Kim Zetter "While the nation was...
No comments:
Post a Comment